The Sporting Director search is still very much ongoing — it was only formally launched by CEO Charlie Boss on 16 March, with the new appointee (whoever it is) tasked with a full review of coaching, recruitment, performance, medical and the academy before choosing the permanent head coach for 2026/27.
No shortlist has been made public yet, and the Hodgson interim appointment plus Struber sacking have happened while that process is live. So my suggestions below are reasoned, realistic options based on the club’s stated goals: closing the academy-to-first-team gap, sustainable recruitment, behaving like a Premier League operation, and giving the new SD a blank slate.
Strong Sporting Director options
These are profiles who could deliver the “fresh pair of eyes” and structural reset fans and ex-players like Gary Owers have called for.
1. Sam Jewell (ex-Brighton Head of Recruitment / rising technical/football operations figure)
One of the most impressive modern recruitment minds in English football. He was central to Brighton’s data-led, value-driven model that turned smart scouting into Premier League success and big sales. He understands integrating academy talent with targeted signings, which directly addresses Struber’s public comments about the pathway gap. Young, ambitious, and exactly the kind of forward-thinking operator Boss wants to “engrain Premier League standards.” Would give fans confidence that recruitment will finally be strategic rather than reactive.
2. Sebastian Kehl (recently departed Borussia Dortmund Sporting Director, 46)
Only left Dortmund by mutual consent on 22 March after years as player then SD — so he’s immediately available and has elite-level experience in high-performance environments, youth development, and smart European scouting on varying budgets. He oversaw a club that consistently punched above its weight in the Champions League while developing and selling players profitably. Brings instant credibility and the “top-flight ready” mentality the club is chasing. Might be a more ambitious target, but the timing aligns perfectly.
3. Chris Badlan (ex-Coventry/Blackburn recruitment/operations roles) or similar EFL-experienced operators
A more grounded, Championship-proven option with a track record of building competitive squads on sensible wages through clever recruitment and player trading. These types excel at the “review everything” brief and understand the realities of the second tier while still pushing upward. They’d work seamlessly with Tinnion in the academy and deliver the sustainable model supporters have been demanding.
Any of these would shift the narrative from “Lansdown family caution” to “expert-led, professional football department” — exactly the lift in general feeling the club needs heading into summer.
Manager fits based on the SD choice
The permanent head coach will be the SD’s first big call, so the ideal candidate must buy into the long-term project (academy pathway, clear playing identity, no short-term panic) rather than just chasing instant results. Here are strong pairings:
– If the SD is modern/data-led (e.g. Jewell or similar) → Rob Edwards or Martí Cifuentes
Edwards proved at Luton he can over-achieve with a young, hungry squad and limited resources while giving academy graduates minutes. Cifuentes did something similar at QPR — organised, progressive football that’s hard to play against. Both would thrive under a recruitment-first SD and help close that academy gap immediately.
Personally, I am not a big fan of either of these. Rob because of his drop and go at Boro, and Cifuentes I simply haven’t got excited by much that he’s done. For me these are two that would be underwhelming decisions.
– If the SD is high-pedigree/European-influenced (e.g. Kehl) → Will Still or Michael Carrick
Still is one of the brightest young coaches around — tactical clarity, high standards, and a reputation for developing players quickly. Carrick has impressed in his previous roles with attractive, possession-based football and a calm man-management style that would complement Hodgson’s short-term “standards and values” work. Either would feel like a proper step forward.
These two are both options I could get behind. I like what Carrick done with Boro, and what he’s doing at United currently. As that ends, unless he gets the full time role you’d assume he would want to jump straight back in. Will Still is one who could be an exciting suggestion because of the story itself. Maybe slightly underwhelmed if he gets it but not as much as Cifuentes or Edwards.
– If the SD is EFL-experienced (e.g. Badlan-style) → A proven Championship promotion specialist who values youth (think someone in the mould of a Gary Rowett or a returning name like Scott Parker if available) — pragmatic but with a clear identity that integrates academy talent without risking stability.
I wouldn’t want Rowett personally, but would be over the moon with Scott Parker if that was an option. That would be one that I feel would get people talking about Bristol City.
Bottom line: Get the SD right (someone who nails the full review and rebuild plan this summer), and the manager appointment becomes the exciting signal of intent rather than a reactive gamble. The structure Boss is building — CEO + independent SD + permanent coach chosen strategically — is precisely what’s been missing. Nail those two hires and the general feeling around the club can shift from frustration to genuine, sustainable optimism by the start of next season. This is the reset supporters have wanted.
For me, I would want, out of the above realistic options either Carrick or Parker as manager – so the SD which would most likely drive that outcome is either Badlen or Kehl.
Thats me doing it the wrong way and picking the SD based on the desired outcome for the Manager.
No responses yet